{"requestId":"3974392b-578c-4446-a3da-d84fdb9029fe","schema":"verity.certify-run/1","ok":true,"tenantId":"recording","certificate":{"schema":"verity.certificate/1","issuedAt":"2026-11-06T03:24:45.061Z","ok":true,"reportType":{"id":"brief-citation-check","title":"Brief citation check — existence, identity and quotation against a stated corpus"},"document":{"name":"brief.txt","kind":"text","bytes":2372,"sha256":"e8be4c9a49ab86d1de2c0ae473d992c5e374c542dcd48927dfccd85bc0bb2a42"},"barcode":"VD-BARCODE-3|core=eb9d39308b9be70dab6e78aed7ccfb37b625b57b@5e06358abe57414d62c7f4b1fe3b3ed8c985cda575cb54876105f65ecbc96d9c|dispatch=37a5d11040ad57a9515a953566551205fe8e2d8b|resolution=ER-RULES-1@iso20275-elf-v1.6|checklist=brief-citation-check@7f99f07a9507114b27267851daa46f264c68fa8e1b439a489513e83bdb4a5e86|spines=cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935@2019-09-09|inputs=brief.txt#e8be4c9a49ab86d1de2c0ae473d992c5e374c542dcd48927dfccd85bc0bb2a42|at=2026-11-06T03:24:45.061Z","storeFacts":0,"answers":[],"statements":[],"arithmetic":[],"computations":[],"answerRefusals":{"schema":"verity.refusal/1","verdict":"refused","echo":{"reportTypeId":"brief-citation-check","document":"brief.txt","kind":"text","bytes":2372},"stage":"checklist","decisions":[{"code":"section_has_no_verifiable_content","reason":"every data point and statement point this section declares resolved to a GAP or a REFUSAL, so it was offered no placeholder. There is nothing an engine could write here that any figure backs, and prose written into that state is padding rather than reporting - so no engine was called. The gaps themselves are still named on the page.","remedy":"not_curable","evidence":{"family":"sections","itemId":"summary","label":"Citations in this filing","engineCalled":false}}],"checkedAt":"2026-11-06T03:24:45.061Z"},"sections":[{"sectionId":"summary","heading":"Citations in this filing","text":"SECTION NOT WRITTEN — section_has_no_verifiable_content."},{"sectionId":"(citation-boundary)","heading":"What this citation report does and does not certify","text":"GAP — CERTIFIED: this report states, for each citation it could read, whether an opinion matching it was located in the stated corpus, whether the case name the brief gives matches the one that corpus records, and - for the part of that corpus whose opinion text is held - whether quoted language appears in it. GAP — Coverage differs by verdict class and this report states which class was answered against what. GAP — NOT ATTESTED: That a citation supports the proposition it is offered for is not attested. GAP — The treatment or current validity of any case is not attested, including whether it was later reversed, overruled or superseded. GAP — This report consults no citator. GAP — That a citation reported as not located is absent from the law is not attested; it is a statement about the corpus searched and its stated date. GAP — Where the corpus searched carries the index for a reporter and its opinion text is outside the text held, a quotation is reported unverifiable in that corpus by name, which is a statement about our holdings and never a finding against this document."},{"sectionId":"(citations)","heading":"Citations, checked against the stated corpus","text":"GAP — CERTIFIED: 5 citation(s) were read from this document, of which 5 state a volume, a reporter and a page. GAP — Against the corpus searched - cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, 471,479 opinions, as of 2019-09-09 - 4 located an opinion, 1 did not, and 0 name a reporter or a volume that corpus does not carry. GAP — NOT CERTIFIED: that a citation reported as not located is absent from the law. GAP — The corpus searched stops at 2019-09-09 and carries two reporters; a case decided since, or published elsewhere, is outside it rather than absent from it. GAP — 0 citation-shaped run(s) were read and DECLINED by the declared grammar, and each is listed with the characters the document wrote, so what this report did not check is visible rather than silent. GAP — CERTIFIED PER VERDICT CLASS, because the coverage of this corpus is not uniform. GAP — Existence, case-name and impossibility verdicts were answered against the whole index of 471,479 opinions, covering F.3d(1-935), U.S.(1-572). GAP — Quotation and pinpoint verdicts were answered only where this corpus holds the opinion text, which is F.3d(1-935), 935 volume(s) held; U.S.(1-572), 572 volume(s) held. GAP — 1 quotation(s) in this document were checked against held text; 0 named an opinion this corpus located and whose text is outside the text held, and each is reported unverifiable in this corpus by name - a statement about what we hold rather than a finding against this document. GAP — no part of this quotation was located in the held opinion. This has been the unmist\". ⚠ THE HELD CORPUS IS OCR'd FROM BOUND VOLUMES and a character it misread is a difference this check cannot tell from a misquotation for \"393 U.S\" GAP — the brief names \"Whitlock v. Farraday\"; the opinion the corpus holds at 424 U.S. 319 is \"Mathews v."}],"sectionOutcomes":[{"sectionId":"summary","heading":"Citations in this filing","modelTextVerbatim":"","engine":{"called":false,"ok":false,"code":"section_has_no_verifiable_content","reason":"every data point and statement point this section declares resolved to a GAP or a REFUSAL, so it was offered no placeholder. There is nothing an engine could write here that any figure backs, and prose written into that state is padding rather than reporting - so no engine was called. The gaps themselves are still named on the page."},"decision":{"code":"section_has_no_verifiable_content","reason":"every data point and statement point this section declares resolved to a GAP or a REFUSAL, so it was offered no placeholder. There is nothing an engine could write here that any figure backs, and prose written into that state is padding rather than reporting - so no engine was called. The gaps themselves are still named on the page.","remedy":"not_curable","evidence":{"family":"sections","itemId":"summary","label":"Citations in this filing","engineCalled":false}}}],"verification":{"reportId":"brief-citation-check","sections":[{"sectionId":"summary","heading":"Citations in this filing","text":"SECTION NOT WRITTEN — section_has_no_verifiable_content."},{"sectionId":"(citation-boundary)","heading":"What this citation report does and does not certify","text":"GAP — CERTIFIED: this report states, for each citation it could read, whether an opinion matching it was located in the stated corpus, whether the case name the brief gives matches the one that corpus records, and - for the part of that corpus whose opinion text is held - whether quoted language appears in it. GAP — Coverage differs by verdict class and this report states which class was answered against what. GAP — NOT ATTESTED: That a citation supports the proposition it is offered for is not attested. GAP — The treatment or current validity of any case is not attested, including whether it was later reversed, overruled or superseded. GAP — This report consults no citator. GAP — That a citation reported as not located is absent from the law is not attested; it is a statement about the corpus searched and its stated date. GAP — Where the corpus searched carries the index for a reporter and its opinion text is outside the text held, a quotation is reported unverifiable in that corpus by name, which is a statement about our holdings and never a finding against this document."},{"sectionId":"(citations)","heading":"Citations, checked against the stated corpus","text":"GAP — CERTIFIED: 5 citation(s) were read from this document, of which 5 state a volume, a reporter and a page. GAP — Against the corpus searched - cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, 471,479 opinions, as of 2019-09-09 - 4 located an opinion, 1 did not, and 0 name a reporter or a volume that corpus does not carry. GAP — NOT CERTIFIED: that a citation reported as not located is absent from the law. GAP — The corpus searched stops at 2019-09-09 and carries two reporters; a case decided since, or published elsewhere, is outside it rather than absent from it. GAP — 0 citation-shaped run(s) were read and DECLINED by the declared grammar, and each is listed with the characters the document wrote, so what this report did not check is visible rather than silent. GAP — CERTIFIED PER VERDICT CLASS, because the coverage of this corpus is not uniform. GAP — Existence, case-name and impossibility verdicts were answered against the whole index of 471,479 opinions, covering F.3d(1-935), U.S.(1-572). GAP — Quotation and pinpoint verdicts were answered only where this corpus holds the opinion text, which is F.3d(1-935), 935 volume(s) held; U.S.(1-572), 572 volume(s) held. GAP — 1 quotation(s) in this document were checked against held text; 0 named an opinion this corpus located and whose text is outside the text held, and each is reported unverifiable in this corpus by name - a statement about what we hold rather than a finding against this document. GAP — no part of this quotation was located in the held opinion. This has been the unmist\". ⚠ THE HELD CORPUS IS OCR'd FROM BOUND VOLUMES and a character it misread is a difference this check cannot tell from a misquotation for \"393 U.S\" GAP — the brief names \"Whitlock v. Farraday\"; the opinion the corpus holds at 424 U.S. 319 is \"Mathews v."}],"findings":[{"cls":"unverifiable_quantity","sectionId":"(citations)","detail":"quantity [\"first\"] came out of no slot in this sentence - 0 slot(s) here back only what they wrote","removed":"The first 114 of its 150 characters do appear there, and then the brief reads \"association at the schoolhouse gate.\" where the opinion reads \"expression at the schoolhouse gate."},{"cls":"unverifiable_quantity","sectionId":"(citations)","detail":"quantity [\"two\"] came out of no slot in this sentence - 0 slot(s) here back only what they wrote","removed":"Eldridge\", and the two captions share no distinctive party name for \"424 U.S\" GAP — no opinion matching this citation was located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, 471,479 opinions, as of 2019-09-09) for \"411 U.S\""},{"cls":"untraced_figure","sectionId":"(citations)","detail":"figure \"393\" came out of no slot"},{"cls":"untraced_figure","sectionId":"(citations)","detail":"figure \"424\" came out of no slot"},{"cls":"untraced_figure","sectionId":"(citations)","detail":"figure \"319\" came out of no slot"}],"counts":{"unverifiable_quantity":2,"untraced_figure":3},"sentencesShipped":5,"sentencesRemoved":2,"figuresShipped":3,"gapsNamed":0,"errorRate":0.7142857142857143,"coverageFactor":2,"coverageFactorSource":"ruled_default","coverageFactorStatement":"k = 2 (the GUM convention) — this report type sets none","provenance":[]},"slots":[],"computationBoundary":{"certifies":"CERTIFIED: nothing under this boundary. This report type declares no computation and no arithmetic check.","doesNotCertify":"NOT ATTESTED\nThis certificate does not attest the result of any computation or arithmetic check under this boundary, because its report type declares none."},"coverageBoundary":{"certifies":"CERTIFIED: nothing under this boundary. This report type declares no coverage boundary.","doesNotCertify":"NOT ATTESTED\nThis certificate does not attest, under this boundary, that any item is present in the document or absent from it."},"citationBoundary":{"certifies":"CERTIFIED: this report states, for each citation it could read, whether an opinion matching it was located in the stated corpus, whether the case name the brief gives matches the one that corpus records, and - for the part of that corpus whose opinion text is held - whether quoted language appears in it. Coverage differs by verdict class and this report states which class was answered against what.","doesNotCertify":"NOT ATTESTED\nThat a citation supports the proposition it is offered for is not attested.\nThe treatment or current validity of any case is not attested, including whether it was later reversed, overruled or superseded.\nThis report consults no citator.\nThat a citation reported as not located is absent from the law is not attested; it is a statement about the corpus searched and its stated date.\nWhere the corpus searched carries the index for a reporter and its opinion text is outside the text held, a quotation is reported unverifiable in that corpus by name, which is a statement about our holdings and never a finding against this document."},"citationCheck":{"corpus":{"id":"cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","opinions":471479,"asOf":"2019-09-09","held":[{"reporter":"F.3d","minVolume":1,"maxVolume":935,"cases":141484},{"reporter":"U.S.","minVolume":1,"maxVolume":572,"cases":329995}],"textHeld":[{"reporter":"F.3d","slug":"f3d","volumes":935,"minVolume":1,"maxVolume":935},{"reporter":"U.S.","slug":"us","volumes":572,"minVolume":1,"maxVolume":572}]},"rows":[{"ordinal":0,"kind":"full","raw":"419 U.S. 565, 576 (1975)","block":8,"offset":{"start":204,"end":228},"parsed":{"volume":419,"reporter":"U.S.","reporterAsWritten":"U.S.","page":565,"pincite":"576","year":1975,"partyNames":"Goss v. Lopez"},"spineEntries":["U.S. (United States Supreme Court Reports, 1875–open)"],"impossibility":{"findings":[],"refusals":[{"arm":"date","code":"edition_dates_unstated","detail":"no edition U.S. names has a stated end, so a year cannot fall outside one"},{"arm":"volume","code":"volume_run_not_bounded_for_an_open_edition","detail":"U.S. is an open edition; the highest volume held (572) is a fact about this corpus and not about the reporter"}]},"existence":{"verdict":"resolved","reason":"located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, as of 2019-09-09)","caseName":"Goss v. Lopez","caseCite":"419 U.S. 565","decisionDate":"1975-01-22","court":"U.S."},"name":{"verdict":"name_matches","briefName":"Goss v. Lopez","corpusName":"Goss v. Lopez","reason":"the two captions share goss, lopez"},"quote":{"verdict":"quote_verified","quoted":"is a serious event in the life of the suspended child.","offsets":{"start":133,"end":187},"reason":"found byte-exact in the held opinion at offset 13972 after the declared normalisation (whitespace and typographic quotes only)"},"pinpoint":{"verdict":"pinpoint_within_case","pincitePage":576,"span":{"first":565,"last":600},"reason":"page 576 lies within 565–600, the span the reporter printed for this opinion"},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:18cb3f10a55e2a1cd4f046127e5184bd","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/citation/citation-verdict@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}},{"ordinal":1,"kind":"full","raw":"393 U.S. 503, 506 (1969)","block":9,"offset":{"start":223,"end":247},"parsed":{"volume":393,"reporter":"U.S.","reporterAsWritten":"U.S.","page":503,"pincite":"506","year":1969,"partyNames":"Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District"},"spineEntries":["U.S. (United States Supreme Court Reports, 1875–open)"],"impossibility":{"findings":[],"refusals":[{"arm":"date","code":"edition_dates_unstated","detail":"no edition U.S. names has a stated end, so a year cannot fall outside one"},{"arm":"volume","code":"volume_run_not_bounded_for_an_open_edition","detail":"U.S. is an open edition; the highest volume held (572) is a fact about this corpus and not about the reporter"}]},"existence":{"verdict":"resolved","reason":"located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, as of 2019-09-09)","caseName":"Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District","caseCite":"393 U.S. 503","decisionDate":"1969-02-24","court":"U.S."},"name":{"verdict":"name_matches","briefName":"Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District","corpusName":"Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District","reason":"the two captions share tinker, moines, independent, community, school, district"},"quote":{"verdict":"quote_not_found","quoted":"It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or association at the schoolhouse gate.","offsets":{"start":250,"end":400},"diff":"It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or association at the schoolhouse gate.","reason":"no part of this quotation was located in the held opinion. The first 114 of its 150 characters do appear there, and then the brief reads \"association at the schoolhouse gate.\" where the opinion reads \"expression at the schoolhouse gate. This has been the unmist\". ⚠ THE HELD CORPUS IS OCR'd FROM BOUND VOLUMES and a character it misread is a difference this check cannot tell from a misquotation"},"pinpoint":{"verdict":"pinpoint_within_case","pincitePage":506,"span":{"first":503,"last":526},"reason":"page 506 lies within 503–526, the span the reporter printed for this opinion"},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:5bf9d0fa7f90aefd30db650ab8d71cbf","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/citation/citation-verdict@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}},{"ordinal":2,"kind":"full","raw":"424 U.S. 319, 335 (1976)","block":11,"offset":{"start":38,"end":62},"parsed":{"volume":424,"reporter":"U.S.","reporterAsWritten":"U.S.","page":319,"pincite":"335","year":1976,"partyNames":"Whitlock v. Farraday"},"spineEntries":["U.S. (United States Supreme Court Reports, 1875–open)"],"impossibility":{"findings":[],"refusals":[{"arm":"date","code":"edition_dates_unstated","detail":"no edition U.S. names has a stated end, so a year cannot fall outside one"},{"arm":"volume","code":"volume_run_not_bounded_for_an_open_edition","detail":"U.S. is an open edition; the highest volume held (572) is a fact about this corpus and not about the reporter"}]},"existence":{"verdict":"resolved","reason":"located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, as of 2019-09-09)","caseName":"Mathews v. Eldridge","caseCite":"424 U.S. 319","decisionDate":"1976-02-24","court":"U.S."},"name":{"verdict":"cites_different_case","briefName":"Whitlock v. Farraday","corpusName":"Mathews v. Eldridge","reason":"the brief names \"Whitlock v. Farraday\"; the opinion the corpus holds at 424 U.S. 319 is \"Mathews v. Eldridge\", and the two captions share no distinctive party name"},"quote":{"verdict":"no_quote_in_brief","reason":"no quotation is attached to this citation"},"pinpoint":{"verdict":"pinpoint_within_case","pincitePage":335,"span":{"first":319,"last":350},"reason":"page 335 lies within 319–350, the span the reporter printed for this opinion"},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:d2df4220dbd9cccab293cd40d711ece1","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/citation/citation-verdict@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}},{"ordinal":3,"kind":"full","raw":"411 U.S. 9999 (1973)","block":11,"offset":{"start":471,"end":491},"parsed":{"volume":411,"reporter":"U.S.","reporterAsWritten":"U.S.","page":9999,"year":1973,"partyNames":"Ostrander v. Vellacott"},"spineEntries":["U.S. (United States Supreme Court Reports, 1875–open)"],"impossibility":{"findings":[],"refusals":[{"arm":"date","code":"edition_dates_unstated","detail":"no edition U.S. names has a stated end, so a year cannot fall outside one"},{"arm":"volume","code":"volume_run_not_bounded_for_an_open_edition","detail":"U.S. is an open edition; the highest volume held (572) is a fact about this corpus and not about the reporter"}]},"existence":{"verdict":"not_located","reason":"no opinion matching this citation was located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, 471,479 opinions, as of 2019-09-09)"},"name":{"verdict":"no_resolved_case","reason":"no opinion resolved, so there is no reported case name to compare against"},"quote":{"verdict":"no_quote_in_brief","reason":"no quotation is attached to this citation"},"pinpoint":{"verdict":"no_pincite","reason":"this citation names no pinpoint page"},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:0f845c6bf928068b675ad4baddd0c545","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/citation/citation-verdict@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}},{"ordinal":4,"kind":"full","raw":"430 U.S. 651 (1977)","block":12,"offset":{"start":118,"end":137},"parsed":{"volume":430,"reporter":"U.S.","reporterAsWritten":"U.S.","page":651,"year":1977,"partyNames":"Ingraham v. Wright"},"spineEntries":["U.S. (United States Supreme Court Reports, 1875–open)"],"impossibility":{"findings":[],"refusals":[{"arm":"date","code":"edition_dates_unstated","detail":"no edition U.S. names has a stated end, so a year cannot fall outside one"},{"arm":"volume","code":"volume_run_not_bounded_for_an_open_edition","detail":"U.S. is an open edition; the highest volume held (572) is a fact about this corpus and not about the reporter"}]},"existence":{"verdict":"resolved","reason":"located in the corpus searched (cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935, as of 2019-09-09)","caseName":"Ingraham v. Wright","caseCite":"430 U.S. 651","decisionDate":"1977-04-19","court":"U.S."},"name":{"verdict":"name_matches","briefName":"Ingraham v. Wright","corpusName":"Ingraham v. Wright","reason":"the two captions share ingraham, wright"},"quote":{"verdict":"no_quote_in_brief","reason":"no quotation is attached to this citation"},"pinpoint":{"verdict":"no_pincite","reason":"this citation names no pinpoint page"},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:0d93eed23bba6503da5a08b2a70f4afd","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/citation/citation-verdict@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}}],"consulted":{"indexLookups":5,"holdingsQuestions":10,"textReads":2,"textReadsWithNoTextHeld":0},"unmatched":[],"tallies":{"citations":5,"full":5,"short":0,"id":0,"supra":0,"existence":{"resolved":4,"not_located":1},"name":{"name_matches":3,"cites_different_case":1,"no_resolved_case":1},"quote":{"quote_verified":1,"quote_not_found":1,"no_quote_in_brief":3},"pinpoint":{"pinpoint_within_case":3,"no_pincite":2},"chain":{},"impossible":0,"unmatchedShapes":0,"quoteUnverifiableWithResolvedCase":0},"derivation":{"entity":"drv:5c2ba32ec8b8891ac9e68cd6dc0a4319","wasGeneratedBy":"verity-dispatch/certify/block-summary@1","wasDerivedFrom":["rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","input:document/brief.txt","input:citation-corpus/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"]}},"derivationEvidence":{"derivations":[],"rules":[{"ref":"rule:citation-check/brief-citation-check%2Fcap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935","registry":"citation-check","id":"brief-citation-check/cap-static-us1-572-f3d1-935"}]},"wording":{"family":"brief","templatesForThisFamily":0,"sections":[],"unworded":[]},"signature":{"alg":"ed25519","canonical":"VD-CANON-1","keyId":"vd-2b223ab58835e187","signature":"ZnCBThozSASDq9+sRLnjONwUvAQRQ1Akg3w3OA0WpVcnrP4CrPrnW1VyvBdjqw9qO4kv951VlVkHCz0y4hduBA=="}},"engineConfigured":false,"templateHash":"deab3ba588839315","sizeWarning":{"surface":"full","declaration":"none","measured":{"certificateBytes":23258,"receiptBytes":1993,"coreReceiptBytes":0,"dispatchReceiptBytes":1778,"evidenceBytes":215,"receiptShare":0.0857},"statement":"measured: this certificate is 23258 bytes, of which 1993 (8.6%) are derivation receipts and their evidence section; full surface (no surface declared). No recorded full-surface baseline for this report type in data/provenance-build-run/dispatch-derivation-after.json."}}